Composite vs wood decking is a bigger question in Ontario than in milder places. Boards bake in July sun, sit under snow for months, and go through dozens of freeze-thaw cycles every winter, and the decking you choose decides how much of your summer goes into maintaining it.
This guide compares the four common options, cedar, pressure-treated wood, composite and PVC, on the things that matter here.
The four main choices
Cedar, pressure-treated, composite and PVC.
Pressure-treated wood
The lowest upfront cost and the most common choice for framing, even under premium decking. As a surface it is serviceable but tends to check (split along the grain), cup and grey out without regular staining or sealing.
Cedar
Naturally resistant to rot and insects, lighter in weight, and beautiful when fresh. It is softer than other options, so it dents and scratches more easily, and it needs cleaning and a protective finish every year or two to keep its colour.
Composite
A mix of wood fibre and plastic, usually with a protective outer shell ("capped" composite). It won't need staining, resists fading and staining, and comes with long manufacturer warranties. It is heavier and costs more upfront, and some colours run warm in direct sun.
PVC
Fully synthetic boards with no wood content. They are lighter than composite, very resistant to moisture and mould, and suit damp, shaded or poolside locations. They are typically the most expensive option.
How each one handles Ontario conditions
•Freeze-thaw: wood that soaks up water can check and split as it freezes; capped composite and PVC absorb very little water.
•Snow and shovelling: plastic shovels are safe on all four; metal edges scratch wood and can mark capped boards.
•Salt and ice melt: many composite makers list which de-icers are safe; check the warranty before using any.
•Summer heat: darker composite and PVC boards get hot in full sun, so lighter colours suit south- and west-facing decks.
•Shade and damp: shaded decks grow mildew on any material; PVC and capped composite clean up most easily.
A raised deck needs the right boards on top and solid footings below.
The part nobody sees: the frame and footings
Whatever the boards, the deck is only as good as what holds it up. In the Toronto area, footings need to go below the frost line, commonly around 1.2 m (4 ft), so that frozen soil can't heave them. Your local building department sets the exact requirement, and most attached decks above a certain height need a permit.
Composite and PVC also have their own framing rules: joists are often spaced closer together than for wood, especially for diagonal boards. Always follow the manufacturer's installation guide, because warranties usually depend on it.
Footings below the frost line and correctly spaced joists come before any decking.
Maintenance, year by year
✓Pressure-treated: wash yearly; stain or seal every one to three years.
✓Cedar: wash yearly; apply a finish every one to two years to hold its colour.
✓Composite: wash with mild soap once or twice a year; no staining.
✓PVC: same as composite; spot-clean as needed.
How to decide
If budget is the main concern and you don't mind regular finishing, pressure-treated or cedar make sense. If you would rather spend summers using the deck than maintaining it, capped composite is the common middle ground. For poolside or heavily shaded decks, look closely at PVC. Ask to see full-size samples outside, in sun and shade, before you choose a colour.
Common questions
Can I put composite boards on an old wood frame?
Only if the frame is sound and the joist spacing meets the decking manufacturer's requirements. Composite often needs closer joist spacing than wood, and a new surface on a frame near the end of its life is a short-lived fix.
Do composite decks get slippery?
Wet surfaces of any material can be slippery. Many composite and PVC boards have textured surfaces to improve grip; ask for slip-resistance information for poolside or shaded decks.
How long does a deck last?
It depends on materials, construction and care. Capped composite and PVC boards often carry long manufacturer warranties, while wood's lifespan depends heavily on maintenance. The frame and footings set the limit for all of them.