Whether you need a retaining wall engineer depends on what the wall is holding back. A low garden wall and a wall holding back a driveway are both called retaining walls, but they are very different structures.
This guide explains, in plain terms, when a retaining wall moves from a landscaping project to an engineered structure. Requirements vary by municipality, so always check with your local building department.
Why retaining walls fail
A retaining wall is constantly being pushed by the soil behind it. Add water, and that push increases sharply, because saturated soil is heavier and water pressure builds up behind a wall that doesn't drain. Most wall failures come down to one of these:
•No drainage behind the wall, so water pressure builds.
•A base that is too shallow or not compacted, so the wall settles or tips.
•Not enough of the wall buried below grade, so the bottom slides.
•A wall too tall for its design, without geogrid reinforcement or engineered support.
•Extra load above the wall, such as a driveway, pool, building or steep slope, that wasn't accounted for.
Out of sight behind every block wall: drainage stone and a pipe.
Height is the first trigger
In Ontario, a retaining wall that exceeds 1 metre in exposed height and is next to public property, the access to a building, or private property where the public is admitted, is a designated structure under the Building Code and needs a building permit and design by an engineer. Some municipalities have additional rules, and walls on slopes, in ravine areas or near watercourses may be regulated by the conservation authority.
Even when a permit isn't strictly required, walls approaching or above 1 metre deserve more design attention.
Other situations that call for an engineer
✓The wall supports a driveway, parking area, structure, pool or heavy equipment above it.
✓There is a slope above the wall, or several stacked (terraced) walls close together.
✓The soil is poor: soft clay, fill, or ground that stays wet.
✓The wall is near a property line, a neighbour's structure, or a public sidewalk.
✓The site is in a ravine or regulated area.
✓The block manufacturer's design charts don't cover the height and conditions.
Armour stone and poured concrete walls under higher loads often need engineering.
What an engineered wall includes
An engineer considers the soil, the height, the loads above and the drainage, then specifies the base, the wall type, any geogrid reinforcement layers (fabric that ties the wall into the soil behind it), drainage details and how far the wall is buried. Construction is then built to those drawings, and the engineer may need to review the work at key stages.
Terracing as an alternative
Instead of one tall wall, a slope can sometimes be broken into two or more lower walls with planted terraces between them. Each wall carries less, and the result is often more attractive. The spacing between terraces matters: walls stacked too close behave like one tall wall and still need engineering.
Stone steps and walls break a slope into usable levels.
Questions to ask before you build
✓What is the exposed height, and does it need a permit here?
✓What sits above the wall, now and in future plans?
✓Where will water behind the wall drain to?
✓How deep is the base and how much of the wall is buried?
✓Does the wall system need geogrid at this height?
Common questions
How is a wall's exposed height measured?
Generally from the finished ground at the bottom to the top of the wall, the part you can see. The buried portion isn't counted. Your building department can confirm how it applies to your site.
Do short garden walls need drainage?
Even low walls benefit from free-draining stone behind them, because water pressure is what pushes walls over time. Taller walls also need a drain pipe with a proper outlet.
Who is responsible for a wall on a property line?
Responsibility depends on where exactly the wall sits and any agreements between neighbours. Confirm the line with a survey before building, and talk to your neighbour early.